Cleveland – With the dust settling on the NFL Draft and minicamp in full swing, the buzz around Cleveland isn’t just about Deshaun Watson’s health or Joe Flacco’s leadership, it’s about a rookie with a famous name and a rocket arm: Shedeur Sanders. The former Colorado standout and son of NFL Hall of Famer Deion Sanders is now wearing brown and orange, and fans are asking one big question, Should Shedeur Sanders be the starting quarterback for the Cleveland Browns this season?
The Case
There’s no denying Sanders has talent. At Colorado, he threw for over 4,100 yards and 37 touchdowns in 2024, showing poise, mobility, and next-level accuracy even behind a struggling offensive line. His calm under pressure and strong football IQ made him one of college football’s most watched QBs.
In minicamp, reports suggest Sanders has been sharp. He has made accurate throws, been confident in pocket, and had a noticeable command of the huddle. He’s impressed coaches with his timing and decision-making, showing that his game may already be pro-ready despite being a Day 3 pick. He would bring a spark of energy to a franchise that desperately needs a fresh start at quarterback
And let’s not forget, the Browns quarterback room is crowded but unsettled. Deshaun Watson is still rehabbing. Joe Flacco is reliable but aging. Kenny Pickett is a reclamation project. Dillon Gabriel is also a rookie. If Shedeur keeps outperforming expectations, why not ride with the hot hand?
The Case Against Shedeur Starting
As promising as Sanders looks, starting a rookie quarterback too soon can be a recipe for disaster, especially in Cleveland, where the pressure to win is immense and the leash is short. Sanders is still adjusting to the speed and complexity of the NFL. The jump from college defenses to NFL blitz schemes is enormous. And with the Browns in a “win-now” mode thanks to a playoff-ready defense and solid offensive weapons, handing the keys to a rookie might be too risky.
Final Verdict
Should Shedeur Sanders start Week 1? Probably not. Could he earn the job midseason if things go sideways for Flacco or Pickett? Absolutely. Sanders has all the tools to be a franchise quarterback, but the Browns must resist the temptation to rush the process. Let him grow, adjust, and learn behind veterans. If and when his number is called, he’ll be better prepared to lead.
